A Costly Choice
Synopsis
Selena (Sarah Arabic) is married to Eric (Isiah Maxwell). But one day, Selena has a chance encounter with a delivery woman, Katie (Lily LaBeau), and sparks fly. Selena realizes that she's not straight, and this leads to a secret affair with Katie. But things get serious and Selena decides she wants to divorce Eric since it's not fair to any of them. When Eric returns home, Selena gives him the divorce papers. She has Katie by her side, revealing that she's been having an affair, and Eric gets upset. Betrayed, he refuses to sign the divorce papers. The two women beg him to reconsider, and that's when he gets a sinister idea: he'll sign the papers IF the new happy couple lets him fuck them both.
Top Cast
Explore Star Directory →
Release History & Theatrical Window
February 20, 2026
VOD & Digital Platforms
Key Information & Fast Facts
- Director
- Ricky Greenwood
- Screenplay & Story
- Lapis Afterglow, Midnight
- Original Title
- A Costly Choice
- Country of Origin
- Canada
- Spoken Languages
- English
- Runtime
- 1h 40m
- Production Studios
- Pure Taboo
Creative Leadership & Key Crew
Ricky Greenwood
Lapis Afterglow, Midnight
Wisamuel, Zsolt Abraham
Bree Mills
Department Leadership Roster
Bree Mills
Producer
Ricky Greenwood
Director
Lapis Afterglow
Writer
Midnight
Writer
Wisamuel
Editor
Zsolt Abraham
Editor
Age Classification & Content Advisories
Official viewer rating standards and content warnings across international classification boards.
NC-17: Adults Only — No one 17 and under admitted.
International Certification Matrix
Adults Only — No one 17 and under admitted.
Production Stills & Gallery
Official cinematic photography and background stills for A Costly Choice.
More Like A Costly Choice
Recommended titles matching themes, cast, and genres.
Frequently Asked Questions About A Costly Choice
Quick factual answers about cast, synopsis, director, box office, and release information.
What is A Costly Choice about?
Selena (Sarah Arabic) is married to Eric (Isiah Maxwell). But one day, Selena has a chance encounter with a delivery woman, Katie (Lily LaBeau), and sparks fly. Selena realizes that she's not straight, and this leads to a secret affair with Katie. But things get serious and Selena decides she wants to divorce Eric since it's not fair to any of them. When Eric returns home, Selena gives him the divorce papers. She has Katie by her side, revealing that she's been having an affair, and Eric gets upset. Betrayed, he refuses to sign the divorce papers. The two women beg him to reconsider, and that's when he gets a sinister idea: he'll sign the papers IF the new happy couple lets him fuck them both.
Who directed A Costly Choice?
A Costly Choice was directed by Ricky Greenwood.
Who stars in A Costly Choice?
The principal cast of A Costly Choice includes Lily LaBeau, Sarah Arabic, Princess Emily, August Skye, Isiah Maxwell.
When was A Costly Choice released and how long is it?
A Costly Choice was released in 2026 with a total runtime of 1h 40m.
What is the age rating and content advisory for A Costly Choice?
A Costly Choice holds official age classifications: US: NC-17 (Adults Only — No one 17 and under admitted.).