Mystery Island: Play for Keeps
Synopsis
Mystery Island hosts a corporate retreat with a guest being Emilia's ex-fiancé. Old feelings become complicated, tensions run high, and allegations arise when a guest is found dead.
Part of the Mystery Island Collection
Stream the entire interconnected saga and experience every installment in chronological storyline order.
Trailers, Teasers & Extra Featurettes
Official promotional previews, behind-the-scenes footage, and exclusive clips.
PreviewOfficial
Type: Trailer • Published 2025-08-14
Top Cast
Explore Star Directory →
Elizabeth Henstridge
Dr. Emilia Priestly
Charlie Weber
Jason Trent
Kezia Burrows
Baroness Jane Alcott
Emily Eaton-Plowright
Ainsley Trask
Kris Mochrie
Franklin Trask
Victoria Bolt
Viveca Bentley
John Macdonald
Spencer Trask
Nisha Aaliya
Patricia Collacello
Barney White
Mickey Carlyle
Suanne Braun
Morgan Bennett
Ben McKeown
Simmons
Randy Domínguez
Ray Romero
Key Information & Fast Facts
- Director
- Steven R. Monroe
- Screenplay & Story
- John Christian Plummer
- Original Title
- Mystery Island: Play for Keeps
- Country of Origin
- United States of America, Canada, Panama
- Spoken Languages
- English
- Runtime
- 1h 24m
- Production Studios
- The Cartel
Creative Leadership & Key Crew
Steven R. Monroe
John Christian Plummer
Department Leadership Roster
Steven R. Monroe
Director
John Christian Plummer
Writer
Production Stills & Gallery
Official cinematic photography and background stills for Mystery Island: Play for Keeps.
Featured In Curated Collections
Editorial lists, community rankings, and cinematic collections featuring Mystery Island: Play for Keeps.
The ultimate Hallmark Channel Movie list 2000-2026 💚
Trying to gather as many Movies made my Hallmark Channel 2000-2026 💚 A list that is missing on the platform and needs to be added Part of the Good Witch TV series Good Witch: Secrets of Grey House Good Witch Halloween
Hallmark Mystery & Detective 2000-2026 🕵️♂️
B Gardens
Full library from Vio, Sonarr, and Radarr - 9,053 items
***2025***
Hallmark Movies
Hallmark movies curated by the Hallmark scraper
500 best 2025's movies
More Like Mystery Island: Play for Keeps
Recommended titles matching themes, cast, and genres.
Frequently Asked Questions About Mystery Island: Play for Keeps
Quick factual answers about cast, synopsis, director, box office, and release information.
What is Mystery Island: Play for Keeps about?
Mystery Island hosts a corporate retreat with a guest being Emilia's ex-fiancé. Old feelings become complicated, tensions run high, and allegations arise when a guest is found dead.
Who directed Mystery Island: Play for Keeps?
Mystery Island: Play for Keeps was directed by Steven R. Monroe.
Who stars in Mystery Island: Play for Keeps?
The principal cast of Mystery Island: Play for Keeps includes Elizabeth Henstridge, Charlie Weber, Kezia Burrows, Emily Eaton-Plowright, Kris Mochrie.
When was Mystery Island: Play for Keeps released and how long is it?
Mystery Island: Play for Keeps was released in 2025 with a total runtime of 1h 24m.