Philip Bosco

as Mr. O'Brian

as Davis Langley

as Doctor

as Walter Wallace

as Otis

as Walter Wade Senior

as Curly

as Det. Sgt. Melkowitz

as Oren Trask

as Professor Clark

as Vincenzo

as Uncle Carmine Morelli

as Defense Attorney Gordon Schell

as Emily's Father

as Frank Turner

as Lenny Savage

as Bus Driver

as Mr. Paulsen

as Franklin Winthrop

as Priest

as Judge Flatt

as Dr. Curtis Franklin

as Randall Winston, Sr. (archive footage)

as Jerry

as Lt. Ray Silak, NYPD

as Sam

as O'Malley

as Paul Gray

as Hollis Nye

as Professor Jergensen

as Mike Killabrew

as Paulie's Father

as Horace Greeley (voice)

as Oswald

as Gene Perlman

as Sen. Frank Steubens

as Brother Paul

as Brian

as Reader (voice)

as Alan Stevens

as Self - Narrator (voice)

as Narrator (voice)

as Dr. Hofstader

as (voice)

as Frank Scacciapensieri

as Other Voices (voice)

as Father Coyne

as Mort

as Dominic DeAngelo

as (voice)

as Fuller

as Benjamin Franklin

as Steve Maggadino Sr.

as Other Voices (voice)

as Dr. Ed Walden

as Dominic DeAngelo

as Gaetano Altobelli

as Narrator

as Judge Garb

as Chief

as Colonel John O. Bailey

as Palermo Racine

as Thomas Colfax

as Self

as Father Coyne

as Peter Stockmann

as Boss William Tweed

as John Wycoff

as Narrator (voice)

as Malvolio

as Art Malto

as Bertram Wolfe

as Dr. Harry Wallenberg

as Dawson

as Patsy

as Gifford Pinchot (Voice)

as Sam Posner

as James Flanagan

as (voice)

as Wycoff

as Other Voices (voice)

as Uncle Chicky

as Saunders (segment "Lend Me a Tenor")

as Narrator

as Judge Garb