Dylan Everett

as Young Dean Winchester

as Sam

as Lance Lancaster

as Seth

as Dylan

as Cam Saunders

as Jake Bouchard

as Alex

as Ryan Burlington

as Mark-Paul Gosselaar

as Isaac Funk

as Boney Labue

as Teddy Cooper

as Cole

as Calvin

as Big Ben

as Andy

as Hunter

as Carl Montclaire

as Marlon Parks

as Streeter / Kid

as Arthur Thomson

as Arthur Thomson

as Himself

as Ralphie Rauschenberg

as Campbell Saunders