John Magaro

as Charlie Geller

as Leonard Peabody

as Frank A. Tinker

as Andrew Hingham

as Dannie McElroy

as Tibbet

as Vince Muccio

as Arthur

as Carl Elias (Age 22)

as Charles

as Victor Polizzi

as Ervin Maske

as Mark P. (voice)

as Cory Staggart

as Ethan

as Silvio Dante

as Nathan Gersh

as Irwin Friedman

as Roland Hlavin

as Clyde

as Geoffrey Mason

as Dean

as Alex

as Cookie

as Desmond

as Cipriato

as Michael Patrick

as Owen Lublin

as Rich Brewer

as Fred

as Detective Chilmark

as Chuck Foster

as Ray

as Young Meyer Lansky

as Alan Brockman

as Snick

as Sean

as Manny (voice)

as Sid

as John Zimmer

as Self

as Keane

as Douglas Damiano

as Cousin Joey

as Keith Jarrett

as Parker

as Dad

as Patrick

as Martin

as Cota

as Robert Lang

as Paul

as Jiggy

as Self

as Self

as Eli Zeller

Role: Producer