Thomas Mitchell

as Uncle Billy

as Gerald O'Hara

as Mayor Jonas Henderson

as Doc Josiah Boone

as Diz Moore

as Kid Dabb

as Henry Barnard

as George Cooper

as Clopin

as Lear

as Judge Henry G. Blake

as John Day Griffith

as Lieutenant Stevenson

as Pat Garrett

as Driscoll

as Tommy Blue

as Ed Morgan

as Dr. Kersaint

as Willie Tulloch

as Jed Waterbury

as Tiny

as John Halloway

as Jonah Goodwin

as Ned Buntline

as Doc Gibbs

as Reginald T. 'Rags' Barnaby

as Cpl. Jake Feingold

as Joseph Foster

as John Plato Beck

as William Robinson

as Gene Gibbons

as Joseph Tumulty

Role: Theatre Play

as Mr. Sydney

as Mr. Thomas F. Sullivan

as Septimus Podgers (segment 2)

as "Monty" Montague

as Fergus Passmore

as Phil Bane

as Mudgin

as Sergeant Kelly

as Kris Kringle

as Father Antoine

as Arthur 'Red' Stanley

as Self (archive footage)

as Old Man Finn

as Dr. Paul Morgan

as Hank Miller

as Noah Tuttle

as Ben Cary

as Mr. Carson

as Kris Kringle

as Prof. Henry Todhunter

as Commissioner Blackton

as Capt. Thad Vail

as William Oliver Gant

as Judge Bentley

as Robert Baldwin

as Hubert Willis

as Vesser

as Dan Painter

as Gill MacBean

as 'Pap' Finn

as Silas Lapham

as Emperor

as Dennis O'Brien

as Sam Hawkins

as Dr. Joseph H. Walton

as Peter Casey

as William J. Grady

as Gandy

as Ike Howard

as Silas Burton

as Self

as Self (archive footage) (uncredited)

as District Attorney J.E. Curtis

as Terence Alaysius O'Davern

as Mayor Dick Williston

as Self

as Warden Michael Howland

as (archive footage)

as Self (archive footage)

as Tom Todd

Role: Screenplay

Role: Theatre Play

as Bertram Rogers

as Grover Cleveland

as Self

as Self

Role: Theatre Play

as Mr. Carson

as Blumenau

as Fred Tupple

as Mayor Thomas Russell

as O. Henry