Jerry O'Connell

as Georgie Cooper

as Vern Tessio

as Derek

as Frank Cushman

as Christian Grey

as Derrick Jones

as Dr. Mike

as Phil Ohlmyer

as Clark Kent / Superman (voice)

as Captain Marvel (voice)

as Lawrence Hart (uncredited)

as Clark Kent / Superman (voice)

as Sheriff Dan Lamb

as Superman (voice)

as Steven Birch

as Clark Kent / Superman (voice)

Role: Executive Producer

as Charlie Carbone

as Superman / Clark Kent / Kal-El (voice)

as Superman / Kal-El / Clark Kent (voice)

as TV Detective #2

as Max Algrant

as Captain Marvel (voice)

as Commander Jack Ransom (voice)

as Ben

as Clark Kent / Superman / Cyborg Superman (voice)

as Highland High Party Twin #1

as Tucker Wells

as Jerry O'Connell / Barry Hatfield (voice)

as Clark Kent / Superman (voice)

as Trip McNeely (uncredited)

as Lancelot du Lac (uncredited)

as Jeffrey Blackmore

as Nightwing (voice)

as Quinn Mallory

as Jack Ransom (voice)

as Joe

as Teddy

as Michael Delaney

as Joel

as Joe Gibson

as Self - Host

as Woody Hoyt

as Self

Role: Director

as Steve

as Father Muldoon

as Michael Penorisi

as Self

as The Coroner

as Mitch Hanover

as Jerry O'Connell

as Self

as Self

as Self - Guest

as Woody Hoyt

as Nick Diamond

as Samuel Ross

as David Lilly

as Businessman

as David Collins

as Jon Dunham

as Self

as Self

as Curtis Marks

as Self - Guest

as Sterling Hamsterton

as Atom (voice)

as Craig

as Lucas Dylan

as David Landon

as Self

as Bobby

as Charlie (voice)

as Scott Foreman

as Jack Burrow

as Pip the Pirate Genie

as Joe Mulligan

as Tim

as Bickering Husband

as Self

as Matt

as Jerry O'Connell

as Self

as Henry

as Mental Man

as Harley Carter

as Herman Munster

as Captain Marvel (segment "The Return of Black Adam") (voice)

as Pete Kaczmarek

as Declan Fitzpatrick

as Doug

as Andy (segment "Rest Stop")

as Self

as Sean Cooley

as Jerry Walkeiwicz

as Brian Herlihy

as Self

as Self - Panelist

as Bob Babcock

as Andrew Clements

as Self

as Reverend Perry Ray Pruitt

as Daniel

as Self

as Self

as Gabriel Kelly/Barbecue (voice)

as Hayden (voice)

as Self - Guest

as Self - Host

as Mac

as Young Ralphie

as Laird Holcomb

as Self

as Lawrence Sellars

as Glenn

as Carl

as Stuart Weber

as Self - Presenter

as Ralph Parker

as Rich

as Herman Munster

as Carl

as Blaine

as Brody Wilder

as Pete Rossock

as Arizona Jones (voice)

as Chad Bixley

as Self - Host

as Rick Brackett

as Self

as Self

as Self - Host

as Jason (voice)

as The Milkman

as Neal

as Attorney

as Brian Herlihy

as Lt. Sebastian Lowe

as Self

as Captain Charles Taylor

as Self

as Self

as Himself - Host