Dylan Kingwell

as Evan Gallico

as Luca

as Young Sam Winchester

as Boy at Art Show

as Teenage Clark

as Duncan Quagmire

as Little Boy

as Joe Rogers

as Sam Thomas

as Young Stephen

as Victor

as Young David

as Sean Keegan

as Ethan

as Arthur

as Max Clark

as Danny

as Peyton Reddings

as Sam Price

as Sawyer

as Himself