Aaron Stanford

as John Allerdyce / Pyro

as John Allerdyce / Pyro

as Pyro

as Peter Myers

as Jim Brauer

as Kyle Mackey

as Doug

as Marcuse

as Thomas Marr

as Thomas Marr

as Sneed

as Horace Cook, Jr.

as Thomas Marr

as Pastor Allen

as James Cole

as Hades

as Seymour Birkhoff

as Actor

as Brett Chandler

as Peter Timmons

as Miles Richardson

as Michael Blake

as George Gannon

as Josh Snow

as Skeemo

as Ricky

as Sergei

as Stephan

as Beagle

as Lugnut

as Robert Davis

as Oscar Grubman

as Doctor

as Neal Downs

as Rich

as Will Traveler

as The Man

as Michael Adler

as John "Rugged" Rudgate

as Gabe Winters

as Duke

as Kyle Braddock

as Self

as Andrew Peterson

as Narrator

as Self

as David Logan

as Anthony Tregoni

as Self (archive footage)

as Stephan

as Glenn