Danny Aiello

as Old Tony

as Tony Rosato

as Police Chief Aiello

as Roth

as Sal

as Louis

as Tommy Five-Tone

as Monk

as Mr. Johnny Cammareri

as Carlo

as Rocco

as Vickers

as Self - Host

as Phil Cantone

as Frank Anselmo

as Dosmo Pizzo

as Major Hamilton

as Danny Garoni

as Phil Harper

as Danny LaGattuta

as Captain Vincent Alcoa

as Gene

as Self - Guest

as Matty

as Morgan

as Father Paul

as Tommy Vale

as Conti

as Louis Cropa

as Horse

as Butch

as Papa (segment "Papa Don't Preach")

as Joe Bella

as Self - Guest

as Don Domenico Clericuzio

as Al

as Danny Aiello (voice)

as Frank Pesce Sr.

as Carmine Rasso

as Jack Ruby

as Carmine

as Artie

as Mr. Bruckner

as Don Domenico Clericuzio

as Sal Carvello

as Noah Cairn

as Dominic Ginetti

as Harry Stone

as Ben Katz

as Coach Jacobs

as Joey

as Mr. Rathbone

as Capt. Mike Grasso

as Joe Lieberman

as Dr. Acosta (voice)

as Fabrizio Benini

as Papa (segment "Papa Don't Preach")

as Chief

as Lt. Terry McNichols

as Tony Santini

as Frank Giorgio

as Self

as Self

as Mike Sheehan

as Self

as Joseph Scassi

as Joe McGuinness

as Pop

as Danny Parente

as Philip Devereaux

as Johnson

as Narrator

as Carabello

as Joseph Donatello

as Charlie Buick

as Chester Grant

as Harry

as Master of Ceremonies

as Louis Brown

as Self

as Tony

as Self

as George Sherman

as Frank Tramontana

as Vincent Dianni

as Self (archive footage)

as Nathan

as John Cunningham

as Duke

as Bernie Serino

as Self

as Martelli

as (uncredited)

as Gene Halley

as Lt. Phil Lombardi

as Skip Mazarelli

as Fran Geminiani

as Self

as Anthony Dellaventura

as Randy Powers

as Narrator (voice)

Role: Executive Producer

as Randy Powers

as Carl

as Mario

as self